Is private tutoring better? It’s not a yes-or-no question. It’s a private tutoring question - one that depends on who you are, what you need, and how you learn. Some students thrive in big classes. Others freeze up when asked to speak up. Some need to move at their own pace. Others need someone to push them harder than the school system ever will. Private tutoring doesn’t replace school - it fills the gaps school can’t reach.
What private tutoring actually does
Private tutoring isn’t just extra homework help. It’s personalized instruction. A tutor sees exactly where you’re stuck - not just the wrong answer, but why you got it wrong. Maybe you mix up quadratic formulas because you never fully understood factoring. Maybe you can’t write an essay because you don’t know how to structure an argument. A teacher in a class of 30 can’t pause for you. A tutor can.
In Dublin, I’ve seen students go from failing GCSE maths to passing with a B in just 12 weeks. Not because they were suddenly smarter. Because their tutor found the one concept they’d misunderstood since Year 8 and rebuilt it from scratch. That’s the power of one-on-one attention.
When private tutoring makes the biggest difference
Not every student needs a tutor. But some absolutely do. Here’s who benefits most:
- Students falling behind and too embarrassed to ask for help in class
- Those with learning differences - dyslexia, ADHD, processing delays - who need pacing adjustments
- High achievers who want to go beyond the syllabus
- Students preparing for high-stakes exams like GCSEs, A Levels, or university entrance tests
- Those who’ve missed school due to illness or family issues
Take a 15-year-old in West Dublin who missed six weeks of school after surgery. Her class moved on to trigonometry. She was lost. Her tutor spent two weeks going back to basic geometry, then rebuilt her confidence with real-world examples - calculating the height of buildings, measuring garden plots. By exam season, she scored an A. That wouldn’t have happened in a classroom.
What private tutoring doesn’t fix
Let’s be clear: tutoring isn’t magic. It won’t fix a student who refuses to do any work. It won’t replace good teaching in school. And it won’t magically turn someone into a genius if they’re not willing to put in the hours.
I’ve worked with families who think hiring a tutor means their child can stop studying. That’s a myth. Tutoring is a tool - not a shortcut. A student who skips homework and expects their tutor to carry them will waste time and money. The best results come from students who show up ready to learn, even if they’re nervous or frustrated.
Cost vs. value - is it worth it?
Tuition rates in Ireland range from €25 to €70 an hour, depending on experience and subject. That’s expensive. But compare it to the cost of retaking a year of school, or missing out on university because you failed your A Levels.
One parent told me her daughter was struggling with biology. She spent €1,200 on 20 hours of tutoring. The girl went from a D to an A*. She got into her preferred university course. That’s not an expense - it’s an investment with a 10x return.
There are cheaper options: group tutoring, university student tutors, online platforms. But you get what you pay for. A certified teacher with exam experience will spot patterns a university student might miss. And in high-stakes subjects like maths or chemistry, that matters.
Online vs. in-person tutoring
Since 2020, online tutoring has exploded. It’s convenient. You can sit in your pajamas. But it’s not always better.
Online works well for theory-heavy subjects - revision, essay feedback, formula drills. But for hands-on learning - like lab reports in science, spoken language practice, or even just reading body language to know when a student is confused - in-person wins.
I’ve seen students zone out during Zoom sessions. They mute themselves, scroll on their phones, then say they “didn’t understand.” In person, you see the frown, the pen tapping, the blank stare. You pause. You re-explain. You adjust. That human connection changes outcomes.
How to find the right tutor
Not all tutors are equal. Here’s how to pick one who actually helps:
- Ask for proof of experience - not just a degree, but actual results with past students
- Check if they’ve taught the exact exam board your child is taking (e.g., Edexcel, AQA, OCR)
- Request a trial session. No reputable tutor will refuse this
- Watch how they explain a simple concept. If they use jargon, walk away
- Make sure they communicate with you - not just the student
Don’t go for the cheapest. Don’t go for the flashiest website. Go for the one who listens more than they talk.
What to expect after 4-6 weeks
Good tutoring shows results fast - not because it’s a miracle, but because it’s targeted. After a month, you should see:
- More confidence in class or during homework
- Fewer mistakes on similar problems
- Improved understanding of why answers are right or wrong
- Willingness to ask questions in school
- Progress tracked with clear goals - not just “doing better”
If you don’t see any of that by week six, it’s time to reevaluate. Either the tutor isn’t the right fit, or the student isn’t engaged. Neither is a failure of tutoring - it’s a mismatch.
The hidden benefit: rebuilding confidence
The biggest win from private tutoring isn’t always the grade. It’s the belief.
I’ve worked with kids who told me, “I’m just bad at maths.” After months of being told they were slow, stupid, or lazy, they’d given up. A tutor doesn’t just teach equations. They say, “This isn’t about being smart. It’s about practice. Let’s try again.”
That shift in mindset changes everything. A student who believes they can learn will try harder. They’ll ask for help. They’ll take risks. And that’s the real advantage - long after the tutoring ends.
When private tutoring isn’t the answer
Some families think tutoring is the fix for everything. It’s not.
If your child is overwhelmed, anxious, or depressed, tutoring won’t solve that. Mental health support, school counselling, or even a change in environment might be needed first.
Same goes for poor teaching in school. If the whole class is struggling, maybe the issue isn’t the student - it’s the curriculum, the resources, or the way it’s delivered. Tutoring helps the individual, but systemic problems need systemic solutions.
Private tutoring is powerful - but only when used wisely.
Is private tutoring worth the cost?
It depends on your goals. If you need to pass a key exam, catch up after missing school, or build confidence in a subject, then yes - the return on investment is often high. Many families see results in 6-10 weeks. For students who go from failing to passing, or from average to top grades, the long-term benefits - like university access or career options - far outweigh the cost.
Can private tutoring replace school?
No. School teaches social skills, teamwork, and broader knowledge. Private tutoring fills gaps in understanding. The best results come when tutoring supports schoolwork, not replaces it. Students who keep up with their classwork and use tutoring to deepen their understanding perform best.
How often should a student have tutoring sessions?
Once a week is standard for most students. For urgent cases - like exam prep in 6 weeks - twice a week helps. For advanced students, once every two weeks can maintain progress. Too many sessions (3+ per week) can lead to burnout. Consistency matters more than frequency.
Do tutors help with homework?
Some do, but that’s not the point. A good tutor teaches how to solve problems - not just give answers. If your tutor is doing your child’s homework, you’re paying for a service that doesn’t build skills. Look for tutors who ask questions, guide thinking, and encourage independent work.
What’s the difference between a tutor and a teacher?
Teachers follow a curriculum for a whole class. Tutors adapt to one student’s pace, gaps, and learning style. A teacher might say, “We’re covering this today.” A tutor says, “You struggled with this last week - let’s fix it before we move on.” Tutors work backward to fix foundations. Teachers work forward to cover content.
Can online tutoring be as effective as in-person?
For theory, revision, and written work - yes. For subjects that need interaction, like languages, science labs, or building confidence - in-person often works better. Online is convenient, but it lacks the non-verbal cues that help tutors adjust on the fly. Choose based on your child’s learning style, not just convenience.
Final thought: It’s not about better - it’s about right
Private tutoring isn’t better than school. It’s different. And sometimes, that difference is everything.
For the student who’s quietly falling behind, the one who’s too shy to raise their hand, the one who needs to hear the same thing three different ways - tutoring isn’t a luxury. It’s the bridge between where they are and where they want to be.
It’s not about spending more money. It’s about giving someone the time, attention, and belief they didn’t get anywhere else.
Write a comment